Most speakers, (MEPs, farmers' representatives and academics), advocated keeping the policy at EU level, on the grounds that introducing "co-financing" (i.e. combining funding from EU and national budgets) could mean the end of the CAP. The majority also advocated introducing tools to restrain price volatility, stressing agriculture's benefits for society as a whole.
How the future CAP should look
The CAP needs to be made "fairer, greener and more sustainable", said Mr Lyon. The EU must ensure fair living standards for farmers and ensure equal treatment for those in the "new" Member States, which is not the case today. The "CAP is one of the most successful policies but needs to be adjusted", said Luis Capoulas Santos (S&D, PT), adding that "we should reject any form of re-nationalisation" of agricultural policy, including co-financing.
Farmers, and producers generally, should also have more market power in the food chain. Market volatility is critical, and a tool is needed to manage potential crises, said Mr Lyon, citing the milk price crisis.
"A greener CAP? Yes!" said Martin Häusling (Greens/EFA, DE), adding that the "CAP does not succeed in guaranteeing fair incomes to farmers" and that future agricultural policy should therefore improve their market position to try to solve the problem.
Give farmers stability
"Farmers should be allowed to adapt" to new technologies and new production models, said Richard Ashworth (ECR, UK), agreeing that introducing co-financing could mean the end of the CAP.
The EU needs to give farmers the stability they need to plan ahead and invest, said Peter Kendall of the National Farmers Union of England and Wales. Direct support to farmers is also a key issue for the future CAP, he added, since it helps farmers to cope with market changes.
Delivering public goods
How best to ensure proper use of public spending was another issue debated at the hearing. According to Mr Lyon's text, farmers "should be recognised as main providers of public goods", such as high-quality food production, improved animal welfare and better landscape management and their beneficial effects on the environment and food security.
The EU enjoys high quality standards in its food production, but "this comes at a price", stressed Michel Dantin (EPP, FR), adding that the future CAP must address environmental concerns and "win public support".
Current support system unfair
Most speakers agreed that the current Single Payment Scheme (SPS) is unfair in distributing funds, both among Member States and among farmers. The SPS "has been seen as a right to public funding" said Louis-Pascal Mahé, a Professor at Agrocampus, Rennes, France, adding that "it does not provide relevant incentives to provide the goods society needs".
For the new CAP, "it is not possible to rely exclusively on the market", said Gerd Sonnleitner, Vice-President of COPA-COGECA, an EU-wide body representing farmers and co-operatives. The public "considers CAP expensive, but they do not think about benefits", he noted, arguing that the EU needs to improve the visibility of agriculture's benefits for society as a whole.
The next event in the Agriculture Committee's work on the future of the CAP after 2013 will be a debate with Agriculture Commissioner Dacian Ciolos, scheduled for 12 April.
29.07.2010
MCS-Zertifizierung könnte britischen Photovoltaikmarktes begrenzen
Forscher: Seit 1990 steigt die Temperatur in der Arktis rasant an
05.10.10: Ressourceneffizienz - Motor für ein Grünes Wachstum
Atomindustrie dringt auf «15 Jahre plus X»
DIW Berlin: Grundsätzlich viel Spielraum für Brennelementesteuer
Kohlendioxid-Recycling: Klimakiller oder Kassenknüller?
28.07.2010
Für Stromleitung aus der Wüste: Blaupause mit 800 kV steht in China
Karlsruher Stadtmobil-Kunden können Plug-in Hybrid Prototypen mieten
Unterwasserfahrzeug forscht unter dem Treibeis der Arktis
Offshore wind heads for record year
Baden-Württemberg: 80 Prozent mehr Schiffs-Gütertransport möglich
19.08.10 : Emissionshandel und Klimaschutz in den USA
Röttgen will Windenergie verstärkt fördern
21.10.10: Launch Event für CDP Deutschland Bericht
27.07.2010
Neuer Online-Rechner: Photovoltaik-Anlagen an Wohngebäuden
Bund kappt Ökosteuer-Rabatte für energieintensive Industrie
Brasilianische Ureinwohner besetzen Wasserkraftwerk
Elektroauto Chevrolet Volt kommt zum Premiumpreis
Die Nutzung der Windenergie auf dem Meer kennt nur Gewinner
Stadtwerke Flensburg verkauft Ökostrom über mobilcom-debitel
Bundesnetzagentur: Über drei Gigawatt mehr Solaranlagen im ersten Halbjahr
KfW-Klimaschutzbeauftragter koordiniert Erstellung von Weltklimabericht
Viele Fragen offen für Deutschlands grüne Zukunft
26.07.2010
transpower will bessere Prognose für Wasserkraft und Photovoltaik
Hacker-Attacke legt ECX-Website vorübergehend lahm
Musterkommunen-Wettbewerb: 72 Bewerber erhalten ihren CO2-Rechner
Kleine solarthermische Kraftwerke mit Mehrfachnutzen für heiße Länder
Wuppertal-Institut: CCS als Brückentechnologie für deutsche Kohlekraftwerke unnötig
Ab 26. Juli: Dritte Bayerische Klimawoche startet mit über 700 Aktionen
Flughafen Stuttgart will CO2-Emissionen um 20 Prozent reduzieren
23.07.2010
Wüstenstrom-Konsortium verzichtet auf Namen Desertec
Verband: Bald über Elektroauto-Prämie entscheiden
Fachagentur veröffentlicht umfassende Marktübersicht zu Hackschnitzel-Heizungen
WWF: Verschiebung des US Klima- und Energiegesetzes herber Rückschlag
Klima- und umweltfreundlich reisen: WWF sieht noch wenige Veranstalter auf gutem Weg
US-Senat vertagt umfassendes Klima- und Energiegesetz